| Channel | How you pay | Typical cost | Lead shared? | You own it? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Angi / HomeAdvisor | Per lead + membership | About $15 to $120 per lead by trade | Often 3+ pros | No |
| Thumbtack | Per lead | Varies by job and area | Often yes | No |
| Google Local Services Ads | Per lead | Set by Google per trade and area | No | No |
| Google Ads (search) | Per click | High in trades; clicks, not calls | No | No |
| Google Business Profile | Free, your time | $0 plus effort | No | Yes |
| SEO (website) | Monthly work | $750 to $1,500/mo with me | No | Yes |
| Referrals and repeat | Service quality | $0 | No | Yes |
Angi per-lead ranges come from contractor lead-cost guides that track Angi pricing; the FTC also documented an Angi membership fee of about $288 a year on top of lead charges. Google sets Local Services Ads prices by trade and area, so check your own market in the LSA dashboard.
Take an HVAC shop buying 25 shared install leads a month at $50. That is $1,250 a month. If it closes one in five, that is 5 jobs at $250 each in lead cost. Stop paying, and the leads stop the same day.
Now put the same $1,250 into SEO. Month one produces almost nothing. But the pages, map ranking and reviews keep working after you stop, and the calls are yours alone, not shared with four competitors. These are example numbers; your close rate and job value decide the real answer.
Most owners do both, then cut the rented spend as owned calls grow.
The map pack is where "near me" calls happen. Right category, every service, real photos, fresh reviews. Free, and the highest-return hour you will spend this week.
One page per service, one per town. This is how you catch "water heater replacement in [town]" instead of paying Angi for it. The full plan is on the contractor SEO page.
Text every customer a review link the same day. Reviews lift your map ranking and your close rate.
Traffic that cannot find your number is wasted. Click-to-call, short forms, real photos. See contractor website design for the checklist.
A yearly reminder text for maintenance (HVAC tune-ups, chimney sweeps, gutter checks) brings back customers you already paid to get.
Every channel fails if nobody answers. Call back within five minutes, text if you cannot pick up, and track missed calls. A lead you paid $80 for and answered the next day is a lead you gave to a competitor.
To budget the SEO side, see what a contractor should budget for SEO, then compare SEO pricing for contractors. For the big picture, go back to SEO for home-service businesses.
Most contractors cannot tell me their cost per booked job by channel, and that is where money leaks. You need three numbers for each source: what you spent, how many leads it produced, and how many became paid jobs. A simple spreadsheet works.
A $30 lead that closes one time in ten costs $300 per job. A $90 lead that closes one time in two costs $180. Cheap leads are not always cheap jobs.
Lead generation for contractors usually stops at the first call, but a lot of money sits in estimates that went quiet. A homeowner who got your quote and did not book is still a warm lead, and you already paid to get them. Most of them did not say no. They got busy, or they are waiting on a spouse or a paycheck.
Keep it polite and brief. This costs nothing but time, and it works on every channel above, whether the lead came from a platform, an ad or your own website. Track closed estimates by source too, so your cost per job reflects the follow-up, not just the first call.
The best long-term source is the one you own: your Google Business Profile and website ranking in your towns. Paid platforms fill gaps while that builds.
Shared platform leads commonly run about $15 to $120 each depending on trade, per guides tracking Angi pricing. SEO has no per-lead cost, just a monthly fee.
They can fill a calendar fast, but they are often shared with several pros and stop when you stop paying. Track your close rate before you decide.
Optimize your Google Business Profile, collect reviews, and build service and town pages that rank.
Within five minutes if you can. Slow response wastes whatever the lead cost.
I will look at where your calls come from today and what it would take to own more of them. Book a free 30-minute call, or request the free 24-hour audit.

I specialize in home services SEO: taking websites that sit invisible on page three and turning them into the business Google and ChatGPT recommend first. I started on the developer side, writing software and doing SEO on the side, until I saw how much home-service owners were overpaying for work that quietly hurt them. So I built a method that fixes the broken technical work and the outdated thinking behind it.
From garage door companies to plumbers, roofers, locksmiths and cleaning services, the playbook is the same: rank where your customers actually search, earn real reviews, and back it with a fast site that books the job. No PBNs, no bought reviews, no directory spam. Only work that survives Google’s next five updates. See exactly how it’s priced on the pricing page.
Free 30-minute strategy call
Send me your site and I’ll send back a free audit: what’s broken, what it’s costing you in calls, and the first three fixes.
No spam and no sales pitch. Just a clear look at what’s leaking leads.